Tuesday, April 7, 2009

The Vegetational fatherhood represents the ultimate communal with nature, where nature and man are able to become one and reproduce. The romantic movement was very influenced by the beauty and mystery of nature, so it seems natural that a writer would go as far as to want the two entities to breed. It seems that the combination of the roses and the woman has created an even better creature. Unfortunately her demise can show the opposition to the romantic movement. Her husband, a doctor and therefore a man of science throws his bride out the window because she looks like a rose bush. Perhaps the author wanted us to begin thinking about nature as human, that the life of a rosebush has the same value as a human life. When the girl looks like a rose bush the doctor throws her out the window without care, because to him she looks like a worthless plant. In fact it is his lovely bride, and by getting ride of the plant, he kills his wife. 
The mother's dream in which the rose bush actually transforms into a man gives the reader the idea that nature and plants have the ability to take on human form. By transforming into man, nature shows us the readers that we two are not that different, that we have the same needs and desires, as well as emotions. The child is devoted to her father, and therefore turns into a rosebush every night. She is the perfect child because she is half way between nature and humanity. She is able to experience both worlds and live in a true Romantic state, able to reach the sublime.

3 comments:

  1. I don't think that we can take the narrator's/author's concern for the rosebush as a desire to literally equate nature and humanity. To me that seems to come off as environmentalism more than Romanticism. Had this event (although absurd, of course) actually happened to some poor individual even in the height of the Romantic era by the most active Romanticist, the results would hardly have differed. Instead, I believe that it is a message to return to the magical, as was not an uncommon cry in the face of the scientific advancements of the day making daily discoveries that shed light on some questions that were more mystical before they were answered.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I do agree that Mynona hopes to alter our view of nature. Perhaps we are not meant to view nature specifically as human, but rather to regard nature with the same respect we do to humans. We place such significant value on humanity because we are narcissistic. Why do we not place similar values on nature and animals?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really like how you connect the girl's close connection with nature as an experience of the sublime. However, I am not sure that the point is that the girl is literally half-nature but is perhaps her respect/communion with nature.

    ReplyDelete