Tuesday, January 27, 2009

James Thurber

Thurber wrote his version of little red riding hood in the WWII era, when the world was experiencing a time of great social upheaval. This included a loss of innocence, children witnessed many atrocities , so the idea of the overly innocent and naive protagonist didn't work anymore. Thurber keeps the fairytale atmosphere by having the wolf know where little red riding hood is, and where she is going without having to ask. The wolf's character doesn't evolve, but sticks to its original plan to disguise itself as the grandmother.  The major change Thurber makes to the plot is that little red riding hood recognizes that the wolf is in fact not her grandmother. This part of the story has always bothered be because, even after factoring in that these stories  occurred before the mass testing and distribution of eye glasses, the difference between a grandmother and a wolf is so huge that anyone, no matter how young or stupid should recognize that something is wrong. I like that Thurber adds that little red riding hood show that it was the wolf from over 25 ft away, emphasizing how obvious the impostor's feeble costume was. I love that little red riding hood pulls out an automatic from her basket and shoots the wolf dead. The abruptness of the action is rather shocking, but the substitution of the gun for the scissors or ax is just a reflection of the time. The moral posed at the end is almost a response to the moral at the end of Perrault's version. Perrault warns the young and beautiful women against all kinds of wolves, and Thurber informs the reader that little girls (and women) have changed, and are not so easy to trick as they once were. This moral may reflect the changing roles of women in society after the war. Women were now in the workplace, many had actually fought in the war, and they had all suffered immense hardship. In Thurber's version, the innocent have learned to defend themselves and stand up to defeat evil.

3 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like how you point out the significance of the time period during which Thurber wrote his version of Little Red Riding Hood. I agree that the change in Little Red Riding Hood's reaction to the wolf and the moral at the end of tale could reflect an impending change in a woman's place in society after WWII. With the emergence of the Rosie the Riveter type female during WWII, the role of women in the workforce and consequently in American society would change forever. This change probably seemed just as radical to Americans during WWII as the changes Thurber made to this fairy tale seem to readers cognizant of previous versions of the tale. The moral at the end could then be a warning to American men that after WWII women might not simply go back to living their lives as they had prior to the war.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The independence of Little Red Riding Hood is indeed a reflection of women breaking free of traditional social norms, as well as having to go to work while men were at war. Also, with the feminism movement, women who read this story would greater appreciate the strength of the protagonist in the Thurber version - instead of an innocent, naive, little girl.

    ReplyDelete